Paper Ghosts by Sarah Addison Allen
9/1/26; 288 pages
St. Martin's Press
Paper Ghosts by Sarah Addison Allen is a recommended Southern Gothic ghost story permeated with generational family secrets and a hint of magic realism. It follows two grandmothers in the Wester family, one in 1976 and her granddaughter in the present day.
1976: In Hen Town, North Carolina, Alice Wester runs the town. She knows all the secrets and isn't hesitant about using them to her advantage. Living with her is her 18 year-old granddaughter Willamena (Wills) who will be graduating from high school soon and is then set to marry Terrence Wester, a fourth cousin chosen by her grandmother for Wills. When former resident Andy Smooth offers to give the high school a free concert, it results in Smooth kicking Jack Vaughn out of the band. Wills is immediately taken with Vaughn, which has repercussions and ends disastrously.
Present Day: Willamena is now the matriarch of the Wester family and she has taken her grandmother's position in the town. She has the same gift her grandmother had and has her own rules. Will's son Terrence (Tug) arrives with his daughter/her granddaughter Bailey after the death of her mother. Bailey is instructed to call Wills, "Mim." She lives there through high school, discovers she has the same gift her grandmother has, leaves after an "event." In the final part of the novel Bailey returns eight years later.
The opening section set in 1976 was intriguing and displayed potential for an interesting novel. Then the abrupt jump decades ahead in time left my interest behind, still yearning to complete the 1976 plot thread. This disjointed experience continued with Bailey, seeing her through high school and subsequently jumping ahead another eight years. A person as a child or at 18 is not the same person when they are 30, 40, etc. and have faced life, with all the dilemmas, consequences, struggles, and, hopefully, overcoming them. There are secrets and betrayals throughout.
All of these jumps in time simply served to destroy the pacing, character development, and ultimately my interest. Wills was left as a husk of a character. Certainly Bailey learns long-buried secrets connected with the ghosts, but the price was the lack of character development and pacing. I'm not a huge fan of straight-up ghost stories, per se, but appreciate Southern Gothic fiction, and this seemed to veer too far into the ghost territory, leaving some more nuanced magical realism behind. In the end I realized that I am definitely not the target reader for this novel. 2.5 but rounded up for the prose and the book cover.
Paper Ghosts would be a good choice for those who enjoy supernatural stories. Thanks to St. Martin's Press for providing me with an advance reader's copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and expresses my honest opinion.























