
Missing Molly by Natalie Barelli
10/20/26 (originally 1/5/18); 336 pages
Poisoned Pen Press
Missing Molly by Natalie Barelli is a highly recommended psychological thriller following a cold case where the answers are closer than they know. This is a re-release of the book originally published on 1/5/2018.
Rachel Holloway returns from vacation to learn that the South Hackney Herald, the newspaper where she works, has 8 weeks to turn things around or they will have to close. Her boss, Chris Masterson has a plan coordinated with the new guy, Jacob, to do an investigative true-crime podcast looking into a cold case from 12 years early. They are going to find out what happened to twelve-year-old Molly Forster. Her father, mother, and sister Grace were brutally murdered, but Molly disappeared and was never seen or found again. Rachel's best friend, Vivian is thrilled with the idea. Rachel is not because she IS Molly Forester and she has spent years hiding from the killer. Three people know what happened and she is one of them.
This is certainly an entertaining thriller that will hold your complete attention. The fast-pace and short chapters work together to keep the narrative moving along. Because Rachel is Molly, readers are provided with inside information and details about her life, which is kept from her colleagues for the majority of the novel. She knows who did it and she also knows she is in danger if her identity is expose. Included in the novel are written scripts from the podcast. There are several times where the plot takes an unbelievable turn and/or you will have to set disbelief aside. The unbelievable plot points seem to multiple toward the end.
Rachel/Molly is portrayed as a complex character with several major weaknesses. Other characters are also developed, although Rachel's best friend, Vivian, never really felt like a trustworthy friend to me. Because Rachel is involved with the podcast she also knows the direction of their research and can try to control what is happening without giving away her secret. This does bring several questions and doubts to mind and is not believable at all based on her role at the paper. In my final assessment, the novel is entertaining enough to overlook the flaws.
Missing Molly is a good choice for those who enjoy psychological thrillers and can set aside disbelief. Thanks to Poisoned Pen Press for providing me with an advance reader's copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and expresses my honest opinion.





