
11/10/26; 296 pages
Akashic Books
Joe and Sam are 28-year-old Jewish twin brothers who have been estranged and are about to see each other at their ten-year high school reunion in Chicago. Both twins tell their story in alternating first-person chapters. Joe, an actor, is flying from Paris seated next to Broadway actor Anthony Rapp, the original star of Rent, and he tells his story to Rapp in his chapters. Sam, a writer, has been living in Aix-en-Provence, France, for several years where he works as a guide for Ramble. He reflects on the past after meeting with Isaac, an old high school friend who offers him a book deal. The problem between the brothers began back with their high schools production of the musical Rent, and with Chloe, who was Sam’s first love, but also had a history with Joe.
Part of the goal of the novel, beyond telling an entertaining story, is to show readers the dichotomy identical twins face, along with all the various ways twins are portrayed as they struggle to differentiate themselves as individuals. Even siblings who grow up together can feel a close bond, but twins know each other intimately. Along with the obvious looking like each other, they know each others background, triggers, shortcomings, dreams, and insecurities. This alone could explain the desire for some distance and autonomy from each other as they get older. As brother is pitted against brother, there is no good side/choice.
I classified this as a bro drama because, well, it feels like a bro book with partying, lots of talking smack, relationship talk, humor, and cultural references all from a young(er) male point-of view. As I was reading it became abundantly clear that I was not the target reader and this novel wasn't a good fit for me. I'm, honestly, an older woman, which placed some of the topics and cultural references out of my purview, however, it was worth reading even if at times it was challenging to tell the brother's voices apart and at other points it seemed to meander through topics and events. I'm likely an outlier on this one.
Our Greatest Work: A Novel by Twins is a good choice for those who enjoy very contemporary literary novels. Thanks to Akashic Books for providing me with an advance reader's copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and expresses my honest opinion.





