The Poison Artist by Jonathan Moore
Houghton Mifflin: 1/26/16
eBook review copy; 288 pages
The Poison Artist by Jonathan Moore is a very highly recommended dark atmospheric mystery/psychological thriller.
Caleb Maddox has just had a fight with his girlfriend Bridget. She
threw a glass at him, which hit his forehead, cutting it open. It looks
like their relationship is over. Caleb left the house and is staying at a
hotel. After cleaning up, Caleb goes on a bender to mourn her
departure. He ends up at a bar called the House of Shields where he
meets a mysterious woman who is drinking absinthe. She totally captures
Caleb's interest and imagination. Even while he is drinking to excess
over the loss of Bridget, he is obsessed with the mystery woman and
seeks her out at various bars.
Amid Caleb's hard drinking, he hears from his friend, Henry Newcomb, a
medical examiner, who has a professional question. Caleb is a
toxicologist who also has an ongoing research study into pain and
tolerance levels. Apparently while Caleb has been drinking his sorrow
away, there is a serial killer loose. Several bodies of males have
washed up Henry has a few questions about the lab results they have
obtained and wants Caleb to test some of the samples. Caleb also has two
police detectives questioning him over a man who was at the House of
Shields the night he was there drinking.
The action flips back and forth between Caleb's excessive drinking and
obsession over the mystery woman and helping Henry with the murder
cases. There are a lot of unanswered questions in this moody, pensive
mystery. Really, most of the book will leave you feeling like it is set
in a dark, gloomy night, with everything hazy and vague - as if the
story is incomplete. And it is incomplete for almost the whole novel.
You won't learn what Caleb and Bridget fought about for most of the
book. While you question Caleb's inexplicable obsession and pursuit of
the mysterious woman, you won't actually know the real reason why until
The writing is sumptuous, both beautifully crafted and wonderfully
descriptive. This could leave some readers with the same dilemma I felt.
The quality of the writing kept me reading, but I was growing a bit
impatient with dearth of solid information presented. The clues to the
mystery are extremely slow in being revealed. The strength of Caleb's
obsession with and pursuit of the mystery woman seemed too intense for
simply seeing her after having a fight with a girlfriend that he says he
loves. And the fixation on drinking absinthe...
The ending is worth all the questions and doubts I had while reading The Poison Artist. I
even, briefly, considered setting the book aside because it seemed too
vague, but I'm glad I kept reading because the ending was incredible -
shocking, dismaying, and frightfully satisfying.
Disclosure: My Kindle edition was courtesy
of Houghton Mifflin for review