
The Infamous Gilberts by Angela Tomaski
1/20/26; 288 pages
Scribner
The Infamous Gilberts by Angela Tomaski is a recommended historical family drama interwoven into a tour of Thornwalk, an English manor about to be converted into a hotel.
As a tour guide conducts the reader through the various rooms at Thornwalk, he points out memories, secrets, and history entwined within it's walls that reveal the story of the five Gilbert siblings, Lydia, Hugo, Annabel, Jeremy, and Rosalind, with their mother and aunt and other family members and servants also present along the way. The timeline spans the 1920s to the early 2000s and recounts the history/story of each sibling.
While the quality of the writing is good, the actual narrative, for the right reader, is average, at best due to the presentation. The pace felt glacially slow through over half of the novel and I almost set it aside. Although humorous at times, it is overwhelmingly a depressing novel that establishes a darkly atmospheric setting. It is a short novel so the chapters moved quickly. Each chapter focusing on a specific part or object in the house in the tour, and the narrator tells the story surrounding it.
The presentation of the plot as a house tour/story through a third person narrator and tour guide was perhaps not a good stylistic decision. It made it difficult to connect with or even care about the Gilberts as we learn about all their problems and their dysfunctional traits. Perhaps having each chapter through a different characters point-of-view would have worked better or have one or two of the siblings tell the story.
The Infamous Gilberts is recommended for the right reader who enjoy historical family dramas and The Royal Tenenbaums. Thanks to Scribner for providing me with an
advance reader's copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and
expresses my honest opinion.



